Adverse Eval Examples


PERFORMANCE SUMMARY:
SN Goldie Locks has demonstrated inconsistent performance throughout the reporting period and continues to require supervision to meet established command standards. Although she is capable of completing assigned duties, she has shown very limited initiative, slow qualification progression and difficulty maintaining accountability. Professional development and increased attention to responsibilities are necessary to improve overall performance.

- QUALIFICATIONS: Progressed towards Helmsman and Lee Helmsman qualification but required repeated guidance and additional training to demonstrate proficiency. Qualification remained below expected timelines.

- WATCHSTANDING: Participated in underway watchstanding duties but required frequent supervision and corrective instruction to maintain operational standards.

- MAINTENANCE: Assisted with departmental maintenance requirements; however, inconsistences with attention to detail and time management resulted in additional oversight and re-work.

- LEADERSHIP: Demonstrated limited initiative in mentoring junior sailors and frequently relied on senior personnel for direction when completing basic or routine tasks.

- TEAMWORK: Participated in command working parties and departmental evolutions but required additional encouragement to maintain productivity and complete assigned tasks effectively.

- ACCOUNTABILITY: Displayed inconsistent follow-through on assigned responsibilities, requiring repeated reminders to meet established deadlines and expectations.

- MILITARY BEARING: Maintained basic military standards but requires improvement in professionalism, self-discipline, and personal accountability.

- PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Demonstrated limited progress towards completing required training and professional milestones.

SM Goldie Locks possesses the potential to become a productive member of the command but must demonstrate greater initiative, consistency and accountability. Her performance currently meets minimum expectations but remains below that of her peers. RECOMMENDED FOR PROMOTION WITH PEERS UPON DEMONSTRATED IMPROVEMENT IN PERFORMANCE AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT.




BLOCK # AND #: CO's NJP held DD MMM 20## and concluded on 6 April 20##. Member was found guilty of violation of UCMJ Article 92: Failure to obey a lawful order. Awarded: 45 days extra duty, forfeiture of one half of one month's pay per month for two months (suspended), and reduction in rank.




BLOCK #: CO's NJP held DD MMM 20## and concluded on DD MMM 20##. Member was found guilty of violation of UCMJ Article 92: Failure to obey order or regulation, and Article 121: Larceny and wrongful appropriation. Awarded: 45 days extra duty, forfeiture of one half of one month's pay per month for two months, and reduction in rank.




Evaluation submitted to document reduction in rank as a result of non-judicial punishment held on 9 June 2025 and concluded on 00 July 2025.

-block 33, 34, 36, 37, 38, 43, 45, 46 and 47. Member was found guilty at NJP for violation to Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 112a - Wrongful use, possession, etc. of controlled substances.




- BLOCKS #, #, and #: CO's NJP held on DD Mmm YYYY and concluded on DD Mmm YYYY. Member was found guilty of violation of UCMJ Article 92: Failure to obey a lawful order. Article 86: Absence without leave. Awarded: # days restriction, # days extra duty, forfeiture of one half of one month s pay per month for two months.




CO's NJP held on DD Mmm YYYY and concluded on DD Mmm YYYY. Member was found guilty of violation of UCMJ Article 92: Failure to obey a lawful order. Awarded: Reduction in rank.




ZERO MOTIVATION. Unfortunate that all the best efforts and guidance from everyone in his department were available 24/7 and still were not sufficient to help him. Member continued with daily sub-par performance, which resulted in the rest of his peers carrying the workload.




MARGINAL DETERMINATION. Did not strive nor participate in additional duties or activities to improve personally or professionally. Identified to separate from Active Duty over a year ago, his path has been littered with constant counseling as he continued with his irresponsibility and nonchalant attitude towards everything and everyone.

-BLOCK 20. Member failed PFA Cycle 2022.
-BLOCKS 33-/34. Member makes mistakes at a level below that of a 5-year seaman.
-BLOCK 36. Member fails to meet minimum BCA standards. Member habitually missed 3 required weekly FEP sessions.
-BLOCKS 37, /38, and /39. Member's continued lack of motivation creates strife and heartache among his peers.




NJP held on 13 June 2024, for violation of the UCMJ Article 92 - Failure to obey lawful general order or regulation, UCMJ Article 92 - Dereliction of Duty, and UCMJ Article 107 - False Official statments.




***Awarded NJP Article #, #, and #. Despite this, performance has not taken a hit!***

***All Things Considered, Highly recommended for advancement right now!***






Individual is an underperformer and is inconsistent in their work. They have issues following through on some items. They are great at networking and asking for help and should leverage this further. They are not great at learning on their own because they are afraid to make mistakes.






SMOKES IN UNAUTHORIZED SPACES; HAS BEEN COUNSELED ON SEVERAL OCCASIONS FOR SMOKING IN THE WORK CENTER.
CHIEF ELIGIBLE.
LACKS COMMUNICATION SKILLS.
BELIEVES POORLY WRITTEN EVALS AND THE FACT THAT SHE'S A MINORITY ARE THE REASONS FOR NOT MAKING CHIEF AND SHE DOESN'T BELIEVE SHE HAS RECEIVED THE SUPPORT NEEDED TO SUCCEED.
MEDIOCRE PERFORMER.
DELEGATES ALL TASKS AND RESPONSIBILITIES.
TAKES CREDIT FOR SUCCESSES AND BLAMES OTHERS FOR FAILURE.




Examples can be contributed using this form.